No citizenship for immigrants with disabilities. What is the situation across Europe?

by Ivano Abbadessa - 2013.03.18
No citizenship for immigrants with disabilities. What is the situation across Europe?
  • Share on Facebook Share on Twitter Share on Whatsapp
  • Print

It is impossible for immigrants with disabilities in Italy to obtain citizenship. This is a little-known fact that made the headlines in January when the mother of a boy with Down's Syndrome, who was born and raised in Italy, protested that her son was denied citizenship when he reached adulthood. Citizenship was refused because the boy wasn't capable of taking the required oath. While the home office minister stated that the matter is being investigated, it is still unclear whether the incident was an exception or the rule in Italy and the rest of the EU.

A starting point is that granting citizenship is a matter of domestic jurisdiction for each member state. The Commission, for its part, doesn't state how individual countries should process applications for citizenship by people with disabilities. Based on the limited information available, there are no national regulations on the matter. However, in some countries there are exceptions to the requirements for acquiring citizenship.

Both Italy and Spain consider disability to be an obstacle to obtaining citizenship. According to legislation in these countries, having a disability can make it difficult for an immigrant to comply with certain requirements. For example the need to 'maintain a legal status for a relatively long period of time, which is related to integration into the labour market, is difficult to achieve if you have a disability.

The situation is not much better in France where, based on a judgement by the State Council, it is possible to reject a request for citizenship by immigrants with disabilities.

Austria, on the other hand, is a borderline case. While people with a permanent disability have been refused citizenship because they have not been able to prove themselves to be financially self-sufficient, it is also true that Austria's Constitutional Court is now examining some of these cases and will, in all likelihood, declare some of the decisions discriminatory due to the lack of any exception for disabled people.

In many other countries, however, authorities are permitted to legitimately deny citizenship on the basis of disability. One of these countries is Germany, which, although it has no specific federal regulations for immigrants with disabilities, requires applicants to pass citizenship tests, including a language test. Meanwhile, the UK Border Agency, the agency that processes citizenships applications, has issued guidelines that make people with disabilities exempt from the language and culture tests that are compulsory for citizenship. Similarly, in the Netherlands, 3,800 people were exempted from tests on Dutch language and culture during 2005-2009, due to having medically certified physical or mental impairments.

Notwithstanding the significant variations in different European countries, one thing is certain: in Europe, the issue of citizenship for immigrants with disabilities is not well known, even among experts on immigration and citizens' rights. There is no common framework that shows the situation in each country. This would enable authorities to intervene in cases of discrimination against immigrants with disabilities, and to take action under the UN Convention on the Rights of People with Disabilities, which has been ratified by almost all European countries. Article 18 of the convention says: "Member states shall recognize the rights of persons with disabilities on an equal basis with others, [including] the right to acquire and change a nationality."

 

Related:
  • Now millionaires also number among the immigrants

    That the number of immigrants is growing in relative terms is a given. However, until recently, we did not know that this growth also extended to the high earners of the world. A new trend analysed and described in the recent brilliant paper “Millionaire Emigration” by the Migration Policy Institute Read More.

  • How the children of immigrants gain citizenship

    Italy: Law No. 91 of 5 February 1992, modifying in part the regulation on the means of the granting of citizenship in force since 1912, has confirmed that the children of immigrants born in Italy do not automatically acquire civil status. This is only the case if it is requested Read More.

  • Another route to achieve ius soli

    In politics as in life, something good may just come out of something bad. On the condition, however, that one has the intelligence and the will to turn things around as needed. As in the case of the tragic calendar deferment decided yesterday by the Senate (already voted by the Read More.

  • Five curious statistics about legal immigrants in the USA

    Out of 44.7 million immigrants in the USA, as many as 33.8 million are legal. The Pew Research Center has just brought to light some facts about legal immigrants in the U.S. on occasion of Trump’s very recent announcement of his super-reforms for managing the arrival of foreigners in the Read More.

  • The U.S. grants citizenship to those who don’t know English

    More than 30% of American citizens of immigrant origins in the U.S. do not know how to either read or write in English. Which often creates and obstacle to social and economic integration. At least, this is the snapshot that has recently emerged in the last report of the Center Read More.

  • Britain’s “May Plan” targets immigrants, including those from Italy

    While Italy is divided over if and how to grant citizenship to the children of immigrants, England is planning on getting rid of immigrants altogether. This is true for Italians who emigrated to the UK, but also for many other EU citizens. It seems as if this is the enormous Read More.