Hollande towards euthanasia

by Valentina Ascione - 2012.08.01
Hollande towards euthanasia
  • Share on Facebook Share on Twitter Share on Whatsapp
  • Print

Is death only an inescapable event, or also a right? That is one of the big questions governments are often and often called to face with. In France, the debate on euthanasia has been going on for years, but it made a comeback a few weeks ago, when the new French President announced a reform of palliative treatment.

During his election campaign, Hollande had promised to the terminally ill over 18, or in advanced stage of incurable disease, the possibility to ask medical assistance to end their life decently. Easier said than done, underline the French press, highlighting how Hollande positions appear less clear now than during the days of his campaign.

It seems, however, that the Socialist leader intends to remain faithful to his commitments. In the last few days, he gave mandate to Didier Sicard – National Ethics Committee President in the period 1999-2008 – to explore the latest stages of life.

Sicard and his work team will have to study how to assist the patient in his difficult path towards death, to evaluate palliative care and, if necessary, to define measures meant to improve the enforced legislation: the Leonetti Law, which allows to avoid therapeutic obstinacy since 2005.

Before understanding if and how French legislation will change on this matter, we know for sure that euthanasia was legalized ten years ago in half Europe.

The first country to recognize direct euthanasia was the Netherlands in 2002, followed by Belgium. And, then, with more or less restrictive laws – by Luxembourg, Switzerland and Great Britain, where the interruption of treatment for some disease is authorized since 2002 and the notion of assisted suicide “motivated by compassion”. Sweden legalized passive euthanasia (interruption of life-sustaining treatment) in 2010, accepted on patient demand in Germany and Austria too.

In other countries, such as Denmark, Norway, Tcheck Republic and Spain, the patient can refuse treatment, while in Portugal euthanasia is forbidden, but an ethical committee can authorize treatment interruption in particularly serious cases. Euthanasia is instead an offence in Italy, Bosnia, Croatia, Greece, Ireland, Poland, Romania and Serbia.

According to figures from the Royal Dutch Medical Association, 4 thousand people every year were helped to die since 2002, but euthanasia legalisation in the Netherlands did not translate into a boom of assisted suicide. And this confirms that what is a right for everybody is not an obligation for nobody.

Published in Euthanasia.
  • All you have to know about the living will

    Who can make a living will in Italy? How is it possible to do so? And, what does the current text being discussed by the Senate foresee? The answers to these and other questions are to be found in the guide realized by the Union of the Italian notaries, Federnotai. Read More.

  • The life of little Charlie is in the doctors’ not his parents’ hands

    Parental consensus is not necessary for physicians to pull the plug on gravely ill newborns. This historic sentence was recently passed down by the European Court of Human Rights, who had been presented with the case of little Charlie Guard. A British baby, having computed almost one year of life, who Read More.

  • Video-testimonial in favor of therapeutic cannabis

    “I am able to feel better only because for the last two years, the region of Tuscany gives me marijuana and it completely eliminates my spasms”. These are the words of Davide Trentini, who battled multiple sclerosis since ’93. He tells his story in a video recorded in Switzerland, where Read More.

  • This is how Dutch euthanasia at home works

    If the Italian, Davide Trentini, better known as dj Fabo, had lived in Holland, he and all of the other Italians with terminal illnesses or conditions forcing them to leave the country to end their lives, would have been able to have died peacefully at home. In fact, in the Read More.

  • Holland confirms the difference between a sweet death and suicide

    “Old age is not an illness, but a phase in the life-cycle that should be lived fully”. This is the underlying concept expressed by the Dutch medical Federation, KNMG. That pronounced a clear “no” to the recent proposal that the Dutch government presented on behalf of elderly individuals, not necessarily Read More.

  • In France living wills saved in cloud

    Organ donation and therapeutic obstinacy. But, also a financial inheritance or a will. All of the matters that the French want to put in order before passing away, can be kept in the MemoCloud. A platform that stores private documents online that will be published in the case of death Read More.